Skip to content

Levels of protection for AI access under § 203 StGB

Levels 0 to 5+, each with what is achieved and what remains open. Gosign delivers levels 5 and 5+.

Levels of protection for AI access under § 203 StGB

Read from the bottom up: up to level 5 each level builds on the one below. Level 5 is the top of the five protection levels. 5+ is level 5 with an addition: open models without a US company. Ask your provider up to which level its written commitments reach.

Pyramid with levels 0 to 5+ from bottom to top: in red, AI access without contract, data processing agreement only and EU endpoint, in grey, secrecy undertaking under § 203 StGB and Zero Retention, in green Full Zero Retention and, as a small hatched tip, the separate route without a US company. A bracket at the side runs from level 2 to the tip: GDPR-compliant from level 2.

  1. No secrecy undertaking

    Level 0

    AI access without contract

    What you have: Private or unvetted access to an AI model.

    What remains open: Everything: undertaking, processing location, storage and review at the provider.

  2. No secrecy undertaking

    Level 1

    Data processing agreement only

    What you have: Data processing is settled under Art. 28 GDPR.

    What remains open: Where processing takes place. Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.

  3. GDPR-compliant from level 2

    No secrecy undertaking

    Level 2

    EU endpoint

    GDPR-compliant

    What you have: Your requests are processed in the EU.

    What remains open: Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.

  4. Grey area

    Level 3

    § 203 secrecy undertaking

    GDPR-compliant

    What you have: Your provider has undertaken secrecy towards you under § 203.

    What remains open: Whether the model provider stores prompts and outputs.

  5. Grey area

    Level 4

    Zero Retention

    GDPR-compliant

    What you have: The model provider neither stores prompts and outputs nor trains on them.

    What remains open: Whether abuse monitoring stores flagged prompts for review. US providers face CLOUD Act orders.

  6. Levels 5 and 5+: This is § 203 at Gosign.

    Level 5

    Full Zero Retention

    (Abuse Monitoring OFF) GDPR-compliant

    What you have: The provider stores nothing for abuse monitoring either; none of its staff review content.

    What remains open: The CLOUD Act applies: a US provider is involved. Only metadata could be demanded.

    Models at Gosign: Claude Opus, Claude Sonnet, Claude Haiku and Gemini Flash via Google Cloud.

  7. Levels 5 and 5+: This is § 203 at Gosign.

    Level 5+

    No US company

    GDPR-compliant

    What you have: All of level 5, no US-owned company involved: the CLOUD Act does not apply.

    What remains open: Open models only. The models of level 5 do not run here.

    Models at Gosign: Mistral, Qwen Bildverstehen, Gemma, GPT-OSS, Kolibri, DeepSeek and GLM.

The levels are an explanatory model by Gosign, not a classification by the DAV or the BRAK. The test is whether access to content is necessary: the DAV position (SN 32/2025) allows it with safeguards, the BRAK is stricter, and the question has not been conclusively settled by the courts. “GDPR-compliant” in this model means: a data processing agreement under Art. 28 GDPR and processing in the EU; your duties as controller remain. Not legal advice.

§ 203 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) makes it an offence for professionals bound by secrecy, such as lawyers and tax advisers, to disclose client secrets without authorisation. The levels order what an AI access under § 203 StGB commits to: from private access without a contract to open models without a US company. Up to level 5 each level builds on the one below; level 5 is the top of the five protection levels, and 5+ is level 5 with an addition: open models without a US company. Ask your provider up to which level its written commitments reach, and hold the answer against the table below.

What Gosign delivers, and with which models, is set out on the overview page under What § 203 means at Gosign.

The levels of protection at a glance

Levels 0 to 5+ with zone, GDPR, § 203 and what remains open
Level Name Zone GDPR in the model § 203 in the model What remains open
0 AI access without a contract red no no Everything: undertaking, processing location, storage and review at the provider.
1 Data processing agreement only red no no Where processing takes place. Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.
2 EU endpoint red yes no Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.
3 Secrecy undertaking under German § 203 StGB grey yes grey area Whether the model provider stores prompts and outputs.
4 Zero Retention grey yes grey area Whether abuse monitoring stores flagged prompts for review. US providers face CLOUD Act orders.
5 Full Zero Retention green yes yes The CLOUD Act applies: a US provider is involved. Only metadata could be demanded.
5+ No US company green yes yes Open models only. The models of level 5 do not run here.

Protection level model by Gosign, as at 10 November 2026.

The eight links of the German § 203 chain and the protection levels

The eight links of the German § 203 chain and the protection level that belongs to each
Link of the chain Protection level
1. The data processing agreement (Art. 28 GDPR) Level 1
2. The secrecy obligation (German § 203 Abs. 4 Satz 2 Nr. 1 StGB) Level 3
3. The sub-processor chain Level 3
4. The provider itself as an obligated link Level 3
5. EU region and data zones Level 2
6. Third-country transfer - Art. 44 et seq. GDPR, CLOUD Act, DPF status, and the foreign-service bar Level 5+
7. Training exclusion and retention - the retention matrix Levels 4 and 5
8. Client consent and transparency (Art. 13/14 GDPR) no level: your own duty

Link 6 is only closed structurally at level 5+, because no US company takes part in the processing there. On every route with a US provider, including level 5, it remains a mandatory check: the transfer impact assessment with the DPF status and, where professional law has one, the answer to the foreign-service bar.

Level 0: AI access without a contract

AI access without a contract means: you use an AI model privately or through unvetted access, with no contract with the provider about your data. Nothing is committed to you: not secrecy, not where processing takes place, not what the provider stores.

What you have
Private or unvetted access to an AI model.
What remains open
Everything: undertaking, processing location, storage and review at the provider.

Zone: red

Level 1: Data processing agreement only

Data processing agreement only means: a data processing agreement under Art. 28 GDPR is in place with the provider. Such an agreement does not bind the provider to secrecy under § 203 StGB, and where processing takes place remains open.

What you have
Data processing is settled under Art. 28 GDPR.
What remains open
Where processing takes place. Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.

Zone: red

Level 2: EU endpoint

EU endpoint means: your requests are processed in the EU, and a data processing agreement is in place. The model calls this GDPR-compliant, your duties as controller remain; secrecy under § 203 StGB is not settled by the endpoint.

What you have
Your requests are processed in the EU.
What remains open
Secrecy under § 203 is not settled.

Zone: red

Level 3: Secrecy undertaking under German § 203 StGB

Secrecy undertaking under German § 203 StGB means: your service provider undertakes secrecy towards you; under § 203(4) StGB, you must ensure this. Whether the model provider stores prompts and outputs remains open.

What you have
Your provider has undertaken secrecy towards you under § 203.
What remains open
Whether the model provider stores prompts and outputs.

Zone: grey

Level 4: Zero Retention

Zero Retention means: the model provider neither stores prompts and outputs nor trains on them. Abuse monitoring remains open: it may store flagged prompts and let the provider’s staff review them. Providers often call this “zero data retention”.

What you have
The model provider neither stores prompts and outputs nor trains on them.
What remains open
Whether abuse monitoring stores flagged prompts for review. US providers face CLOUD Act orders.

Zone: grey

Level 5: Full Zero Retention

Full Zero Retention means: the provider stores prompts and outputs neither in regular operation nor for abuse monitoring, and none of the provider's staff review content. The difference from Zero Retention is abuse monitoring.

What you have
The provider stores nothing for abuse monitoring either; none of its staff review content.
What remains open
The CLOUD Act applies: a US provider is involved. Only metadata could be demanded.

Zone: green

Level 5+: No US company

No US company means: everything level 5 commits to, plus open models run by an operator outside any US group, with no US company involved; the CLOUD Act does not apply here. The choice is smaller: the models of level 5 do not run here.

What you have
All of level 5, no US-owned company involved: the CLOUD Act does not apply.
What remains open
Open models only. The models of level 5 do not run here.

Zone: green

Frequently asked questions about the levels

May I use ChatGPT or Claude with client data as a lawyer?

Not below level 3: only there is your service provider bound to secrecy under § 203 StGB. Levels 3 and 4 remain a grey area, because the provider can still store or review content there; only levels 5 and 5+ close that gap. Private access without a contract is level 0. Which level an access reaches is shown by the provider's written commitments; whether you may use it in a given case is not decided by the model.

Is a data processing agreement enough for § 203 StGB?

No, a data processing agreement alone is level 1. It settles data processing under Art. 28 GDPR, not secrecy. § 203(4) StGB also requires the service provider to be bound to secrecy; that is level 3.

What is the difference between Zero Retention and Full Zero Retention?

Level 4, Zero Retention, rules out storage in normal operation; level 5, Full Zero Retention, also rules out storage for abuse monitoring. With Zero Retention the provider may still store flagged prompts and let staff review them, with Full Zero Retention it may not.

What is abuse monitoring, and why does it matter for § 203?

Abuse monitoring separates level 4 from level 5. The provider checks prompts for misuse; flagged ones it may store and let staff review. For professionals bound by secrecy this means content from a client matter can sit with the provider and be read, even though Zero Retention was agreed.

Does an EU data centre protect against the CLOUD Act?

No, an EU endpoint is level 2 and settles where processing takes place, not who can demand access. The CLOUD Act reaches US companies for data in the EU as well. What a provider does not store it cannot hand over to any authority; at level 5 there is almost nothing to hand over, metadata at most. At level 5+ no US company is involved in processing, so the CLOUD Act does not apply.

What is a secrecy undertaking under § 203(4) StGB?

It is level 3: the service provider undertakes secrecy towards the professional bound by secrecy. § 203(4) sentence 2 no. 1 StGB requires the professional to ensure this. For lawyers, § 43e of the Federal Lawyers' Act (BRAO) requires text form and notice of the criminal consequences. At Gosign the document is called the § 203 addendum.

From which level is AI access GDPR-compliant?

In this model from level 2: a data processing agreement under Art. 28 GDPR is in place there, and processing takes place in the EU. Your other duties as controller remain with you, such as the legal basis, technical and organisational measures and, where required, a data protection impact assessment.

Hold your access against the levels

We walk through with you up to which level the written commitments of your current provider reach. As a technical and organisational assessment, not as legal advice.

Book a conversation